Zona Ciega

Retirement

What your Afore charges, what it pays, and how to compare the two

Commissions are now almost the same at every Afore, about 5.4 pesos per 1,000 a year. So the fee alone won't tell them apart. Consar publishes the number that might.

If you’ve ever had formal employment in Mexico, there’s probably a retirement account in your name, run by a private company called an Afore. Plenty of people couldn’t say which one it is, what it charges or how it has done.

The good news is that all three are public, and only one of them takes much reading.

When every Afore charges nearly the same, the fee stops being the thing to compare.

What you pay

An Afore’s commission is charged as a percentage of your balance each year, whether or not your balance grew. Consar, the regulator, authorised the 2026 commissions in November 2025.[1][2]

Nine Afores charge 0.54% in 2026, and the public-sector Pensionissste charges 0.52%. The system’s average fell from 0.547% to 0.538%.[1] That’s a small cut from around 0.55% in 2025.[2] In practice it means 5.4 pesos a year for every 1,000 pesos saved.[1]

So on a balance of 200,000 pesos, 0.54% comes to about 1,080 pesos a year. You don’t get a bill for this. It comes out of the account, so most people never see it as a charge.

Why that isn’t the whole comparison

With nine of the ten Afores at the same 0.54%, switching to save on fees achieves almost nothing today.[1] The gap between them is in the returns.

A small difference there matters a great deal over decades. That’s where Consar’s figure comes in.

The number to look at: the IRN

The IRN, or Indicador de Rendimiento Neto, is Consar’s measure of net return. It reflects each investment fund’s weighted short-, medium- and long-term return, after commissions.[3]

“Net” is the important word. The commission has already been taken out, so you’re not comparing a return on one side and a fee on the other. The figure includes both.

Your money sits in a Siefore, the fund inside the Afore. Funds are organised by generation, so the right comparison is within your own birth-year group.[3] A fund for people about to retire should hold different investments from a fund for someone in their twenties, so comparing across groups tells you little.

What the number can’t tell you

Consar itself is clear on the limits. Past returns don’t guarantee future ones, and it suggests also weighing the commission and the services each Afore offers.[3] One good year shouldn’t move you. That’s why the measure looks at more than one time horizon.

We’re deliberately not listing a “best” Afore here. The ranking changes as Consar updates its figures, and the right place to check is Consar’s own table, on the day you look.

How to check yours, in three steps

  1. Find out which Afore you’re with. Your statement says so. If you don’t have one, Consar’s site explains how to locate your account.
  2. Find your birth-year group. Use it to read Consar’s IRN table for your generation.[3]
  3. See where yours sits. Compare it with the others in your group, then look at services such as how easily you can make voluntary contributions.

If you do decide to change, do the paperwork through official channels. Don’t hand over your documents to someone who approaches you offering a switch, and if anything feels pushy, walk away and ask Consar.

Questions to ask yourself

  • Do I know which Afore holds my money? If not, that’s the first job.
  • When did I last see a statement? The balance, the commission and the return are all on it.
  • Is my Afore near the top or bottom of my group, over time? Not this year alone.

You can’t choose the commission, as it’s almost the same everywhere. You can choose to look.

Terms in this article

Afore
The private company that manages your retirement savings account. It charges a commission on your balance each year.
Commissioncomisión
A charge for a service or an event, on top of interest: a card's annual fee, a late payment, an account that goes below its minimum. Institutions have to publish theirs.
Consar
The regulator of Mexico's retirement savings system. It authorises what Afores can charge and publishes their results.
IRNIndicador de Rendimiento Neto
Consar's measure of what each Afore's fund has returned after commissions. Compare it within your own birth-year group, and remember past returns don't guarantee future ones.
Siefore
The investment fund inside an Afore where your retirement money actually sits. Funds are grouped by the year you were born.
All terms in the glossary

Sources

  1. Estos serán los nuevos cobros de las Afores en 2026El CEO, 21 Nov 2025
  2. Afores cobrarán menos en 2026: estas son las comisiones autorizadasEl Contribuyente, 27 Nov 2025
  3. Indicador de Rendimiento Neto (Siefores Generacionales)Comisión Nacional del Sistema de Ahorro para el Retiro (Consar)