Payroll loan or personal loan: a lower rate can still cost you more
Banxico's averages put payroll loans at 27% and personal loans at 40.5%. But the average payroll loan runs for twice as long, and that changes the sum.
If your bank has offered you a payroll loan, the pitch is simple: a lower rate than a personal loan. On average that’s true, and by a lot. Banxico’s figures put the balance-weighted average rate on payroll loans at 27.0%, against 40.5% on personal loans.[1][2]
A payroll loan (crédito de nómina) is repaid straight from your salary. A personal loan isn’t tied to it. The rate gap is real, but it isn’t the whole comparison.
A lower rate over a longer time can cost you more pesos than a higher rate over a shorter one.
The number behind the number
The average term is very different. Payroll loans average 50 months, about four years. Personal loans average 25.[1][2]
Our own sums below use those Banxico rates and terms on 100,000 pesos, with level monthly payments, and leave out opening fees and VAT.
| 100,000 pesos | Monthly payment | Total interest |
|---|---|---|
| Payroll, 27%, 25 months | 5,274 | 31,840 |
| Personal, 40.5%, 25 months | 5,985 | 49,634 |
| Payroll, 27%, 50 months | 3,352 | 67,592 |
Our calculation, using Banxico’s average rates and terms.[1][2]
Over the same 25 months, the payroll loan saves about 17,800 pesos. That’s the honest case for it.
Stretch it to the typical 50 months, though, and you pay more interest than on the personal loan, despite the much lower rate. The monthly payment falls by about 1,900 pesos, which is what makes the offer feel cheaper, and it’s not a mistake to want that if you need the breathing room. Just be aware of what you’re buying with it.
These are averages for illustration, from different periods. Your own offer will differ, so use its real numbers.
An average isn’t what you’ll be offered
Don’t take the 27% as a promise. Averages hide a wide spread, and Banxico’s report shows a much higher ceiling: 64.9% is the rate below which 99% of payroll loans fall.[1] So a payroll loan isn’t automatically cheap.
Why they’re usually cheaper
The lender’s risk is lower: the payment comes out of your salary before you can spend it. That’s what you’re trading for the lower rate, and it has a few consequences.
- It’s usually tied to where you’re paid. That can make it awkward to change banks while the loan is running.
- The money goes before you see it. Your take-home pay is smaller for years. If your income drops, the payment doesn’t.
- Leaving your job can complicate it. Ask what happens to the loan if your salary stops arriving in that account.
How to compare your two offers
Banxico’s guide says to use the CAT to compare offers of the same type, and to look also at the size of each payment, how often you pay, the term, and whether the rate is fixed or variable.[3] The CAT leaves out VAT, so check whether the payments include it.[3]
The CAT is a yearly measure, so it won’t show you the total pesos. Ask for both numbers.
What to ask before you sign
- “What’s the total I’ll pay, in pesos?” Compare that as well as the CAT. Check it on the cover sheet.
- “Can you show me this over a shorter term?” See what happens to the total if you can afford a higher payment.
- “Can I pay early, and is there a penalty?” An extra payment now and then can take a lot of interest off a long loan.
- “What happens if I change jobs?”
Our payroll or personal loan calculator lets you put both offers side by side, with your own rates, fees and terms.
The payroll loan usually wins on the rate. Whether it wins on the total depends on how long you take to pay it back.
Terms in this article
- Payroll loancrédito de nómina
- A loan repaid straight from your salary, usually at the bank where you get paid. The lender's risk is lower, so the rate usually is too, but the money leaves before you see it.
- Personal loancrédito personal
- A loan for general use, with no asset behind it and no direct deduction from your salary. Rates are usually higher than on payroll loans.
- Opening feecomisión por apertura
- A one-off charge for granting the loan. If it comes out of the money you're lent, you receive less than the amount you owe, and that raises the real cost.
- VATIVA
- Mexico's 16% sales tax. It applies to interest and fees on most consumer credit, and the official CAT leaves it out, so you can pay more than the CAT suggests. Interest on a home mortgage is exempt.
- CATCosto Anual Total
- The total yearly cost of a loan, shown as one percentage. It adds interest, fees and any insurance you're required to buy, so it's the number to compare between offers of the same kind. It leaves VAT out.
- Fixed or variable ratetasa fija o variable
- A fixed rate stays the same for the life of the loan. A variable rate can move, so your payment can change after you've signed.
Sources
- Indicadores Básicos de Créditos de Nómina, datos a diciembre de 2024Banco de México (Banxico), data to December 2024
- Indicadores Básicos de Créditos Personales y Microcréditos, datos a agosto de 2025Banco de México (Banxico), data to August 2025
- Crédito y Costo Anual TotalBanco de México (Banxico), consumer guide